The Wilderness Revisited
J.T. Diamond Essay Competition
The J.T. Diamond Essay Competition is held by Waitakere Library & Information
Services and the West Auckland Historical Society to encourage an interest in,
and the study of, West Auckland history. This annual event is named in honour of
Jack (John T) Diamond, a man who spent a lifetime studying, writing and
documenting the history of West Auckland and the Waitakere Ranges.
Special announcement: This year we have the pleasure of
adding a new prize category - The Morris Photographic
Prize. This prize has kindly been donated by the Morris Family of Henderson.
Frank Morris was a local photographer based in Henderson, and many of his
photographs are found in publications on West Auckland.
Competition Information
The aim of the J.T. Diamond Essay competition is:
- To encourage people to explore and record the local history of West Auckland
- To honour the life and work of a pioneer West Auckland historian,
Jack (John) T. Diamond
Note: For the purposes of the competition, West Auckland is
defined as the area between Avondale and Muriwai.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Competition Flyer (Size 188K)

Closing date
All entries must be received by 5pm Friday 21 August 2009.
Entries must include an official entry form and can be submitted at any
Waitakere Libraries branch, or posted to:
- J.T. Diamond Essay Competition Waitakere Library & Information Services
Private Bag 93 109
Henderson 0650
Essays may be submitted in electronic format. Email to
info@waitakere.govt.nz. Please
attach a completed and signed copy of the entry form.
Please retain a copy of your original research.

Categories
The competition is open to:
- Students: aged 10-13 years
- Students: aged 14-18 years
- Adults (excluding professional writers)
There are two essay categories:
- Memories: personal recollections of West Auckland - either your own
recollections, or an essay based upon other people's recollections and
memories
- Historical Research: original research exploring an aspect of West
Auckland history. See Essay Topics and
Rules below for further
information.
This year we are pleased to announce a new prize category. The Morris
Photographic Prize will be awarded to the essay which uses as its starting point
an historic photograph from the Waitakere Library and Information Services
photographic collections and compares it with a photograph of today.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Essay Topics (Size
830K)
Morris Prize Flyer
(Size 754K)

Essay Topics
Entries must be original historical research on the history of West Auckland,
and include an aspect of any of the following topics:
- The natural history of West Auckland - coasts, forests, streams,
harbours, rangers, flora and fauna, kainga noho, kaimoana, huarakau
- The industry - wineries, gum digging, timber milling, water supply,
pottery, boat building, eco businesses, etc.
- Old buildings, sites, monuments, parks, cemeteries, spaces
- Characters, personalities & influential figures - artists, families,
sportspeople, ancestors, business people, teachers, historians etc.
- A specific event or occasion
- Place names such as Titirangi, Opanuku, Te Wai o Pareira, Waikomiti,
Laingholm, Span Farm, Henderson, Birdwood
- Legends, traditional stories and folklore
- Settlement - Maori, pioneers, ethnic groups and communities
- Jack Diamond the researcher: his work, collections and influence

Criteria
The competition is open to all adults (excluding professional writers) and
students aged 10-18 years
- Entries must be on one side of A4 paper
- Entries should be typed (Arial font, 12 point, line spacing one
and a half)
- Recommended word count is between 800-3,000 words
- Entries may be in English or Maori
- Joint entries will be accepted
- All entries must relate to an aspect of West Auckland history and be
accompanied by a signed official entry form
- A bibliography and a list acknowledging the contributor of any oral,
photographic or other sources must be included.
Please see page 3 of the Researching Local History Guide
on "How to reference your essay'.
- Please retain a copy of your original research
Essays may be submitted in electronic format. Email to
info@waitakere.govt.nz. Please
attach a completed and signed copy of the entry form.
All other entries not submitted electronically may be left at any branch of
Waitakere Libraries or you can post your entry to:
- JT Diamond Essay Competition
Waitakere Library & Information Services
Private Bag 93109
Henderson 0650
Professional writers, J.T. Diamond Essay Committee and Judges are excluded
from entering the competition. The competition closes 5 pm Friday
21 August 2009.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
J.T. Diamond Rules
2009 (Size 52K)

Entry Form
All entries must be accompanied by an official entry form. Hard copies of the
entry form are available from every Waitakere Library.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Official Entry Form
(Size 92K)

Prizes
Prizes will be awarded for first, second and third, in both
Memories and Research categories for
students and for adults.
A prize will be awarded for the overall winning entry across all ages and
categories for the Morris Photographic Prize, Mayor's Prize, West Auckland
Historical Society Prize and Franich Diamond Prize.
The Bullock Trophy is awarded to the school that contributes most to the
competition, not necessarily in the amount of essays, but the quality of the
essays and originality of topics.
All participants will be notified by mail and advised of the date, time and
location of the prize giving ceremony.
View the previous J.T. Diamond Essay Competition Prize
Winners.

Research Tips
Waitakere is rich in history. It was originally known as Te Waonui O
Tiriwa (The Great Forest of Tiriwa). Tiriwa being one of the first
inhabitants of this region from whom the local Iwi, Te Kawerau a Maki, descend.
Many historians have had a passion for this region, including Jack Diamond,
Graeme Murdoch, George Graham and Percy Smith to name a few.
Other historians who have provided a real sense of our identity include Peter
Buffett, Ben Copedo, Anthony Flude, Bruce Hayward, David Lowe, Dick Scott and
Mary Woodward.
Many others, too numerous to mention, have addressed meetings of the West
Auckland Historical Society, whose monthly newsletters are rich in such recorded
history. These newsletters are available from Waitakere Central Library and the
West Auckland Historical Society.
Waitakere Libraries have many books on the history of West Auckland.
These can provide a useful historical context for your research. (Remember,
competitions entries must be based on original research). Use the
catalogue to browse the books held by Waitakere Libraries.)
- Select the Subject option using the drop down arrow
- Type in a subject e.g. West Auckland, Glen Eden, Swanson etc
- Click Go.
Researching your local history: a basic guide 2009
The document below provides a basic guide to researching for your essay.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
J.T. Diamond research Guide 2009 (Size 260K)

Competition Poster
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
J.T. Diamond
Poster Ad (Size 1910K)
About J.T. (Jack) Diamond
Jack Diamond researched West Auckland history for over 60 years. He
accumulated an extensive
collection of photographs, books,
newspapers, research notes and manuscripts. Jack's research focused on the
Waitakere Ranges and the wider West Auckland area, including Maori history, the
kauri timber milling and brick-making industries and their workers, and
pioneering families. He also explored roading, railways, buildings and
vineyards.
Jack Diamond died in February 2001 at the age off 88. Jack's extensive
research collection was donated by his family to Waitakere
City Library and Information Services, and it is available for use by the
public at Waitakere
Central Library.
J.T. Diamond Essay Competition 2009 Prize Winners
Best Overall essay: Franich Jewellers Diamond Essay PrizeThe 2009 overall winner received diamond jewellery kindly donated by Franich
Jewellers in Henderson.
From past to present: George Ward remembers Orchard Life on Sturges Road -
Bella Berman
Judges' comments: This essay embodies what the competition is all about. It is a
celebration of West Auckland, the author has discovered a local treasure -
another Westie diamond, and in turn has created a taonga for the archives. Keep
writing and you will have an assured and splendid career ahead of you.
Memories category: AdultFirst Place
Kathleen Donaldson remembers Franks Store, penny ice-creams and other stories -
Louise Maich
Judges' comments: Kathleen Donaldson is an inspiration, and the author's well
crafted introduction sets the scene for this delightful oral history interview.
Second Equal PlaceHenderson Posties in the Seventies - Gwen Wilkinson
Judges' comments: An interesting and entertaining description of the joys of the
postie in the 1970s. Good fun and a welcome addition to the historical record.
Memories of the Hyde Dunn Property, Henderson Valley - Mary Ann White
Judges' comments: A comprehensive well illustrated essay on an original topic
and soundly based on oral history interviews.
Third Equal Place
Memories of childhood in New Lynn - Cherie Vazey
Judges' comments: An evocative and nostalgic description of a time when New Lynn
was a country town and its streams favourite watering holes.
Notable air pageants, public open days and air-shows at the RNZAF airbase
Whenuapai - Dick Endt
Judges' comments: This essay weaves a passion for aviation history with personal
recollections and family stories.
Highly commended
Childhood memories of Titirangi - Wayne Nicholls
Apple Jack: Frederick Fuller family memories - Trevor Pollard

Historical Research: Adult
First Prize
Glen Eden Baptist Church - Elayne Wilson
Judges' comments: A lively and informative essay about an important community
social service. Good use of personal interviews and historical sources.
Highly Commended
Breath of the Spirit - The Bah 'is in Henderson Valley - Mary Ann White

Memories category: Student
First PlaceFrom past to present: George Ward remembers orchard life on Sturges Road - Bella
Berman
Judges' comments: Excellent piece of work, original topic, well constructed. A
true delight to read.
Second Equal Place
My Poppa's 50 years of Piha memories - Kimberley Halberg
Judges' comments: Enjoyable and interesting anecdotes well told splendidly
illustrated.
Layers: a family deep in Karekare - Maisie Leigh Hamilton Murray
Judges' comments: Well researched with fabulous photographs and a good
combination of interviews and personal experience.
Third Equal Place
Memories of Mr Huia: Norm Laing - Laura Coppard
Judges' comments: A thoroughly researched essay on an original topic.
Now and then - Sarah Dukes
Judges' comments: A lovely sense of a family sharing the experience of living in
West Auckland between one generation and another.
Highly Commended
Through my Granddad's eyes: The brickworks of New Lynn - Mikayla Frazer
The history of Lynndale Sports Club - Kennedy McCabe
My maternal great Grandfather [George Lawson] - Brock Dormer

Historical Research: Student
First PlaceOn the right track! A story of the Waitakere Tramline - Jack Queenin
Judges' comments: A well researched essay with an authentic child's voice.
Second Equal Place
The Swanson Railway Station - Olivia McIntyre
Judges' comments: A personal approach to what has become an important community
facility. Showed a good understanding of the role of the Station as a community
building exercise.
Ponies and people - Erica Wills and Kate Williscroft
Judges' comments: A comprehensive, interesting, well constructed and researched
essay with well chosen photographs.
Third Equal Place
Mill Cottage's water-wheel - Michaela Gilpin
Judges' comments: A fresh approach to this topic with a sense of the
environmental as well as the economic impacts of the timber industry.
The history of Portage Road - Yvonne Porter
Judges' comments: The author shows an understanding of the significance of this
portage. The essay is well researched and illustrated and the writer has come to
a new understanding an appreciation of the topic.
Highly Commended
The will of tradition brought to a school! Te Kakariki Marae - Victoria
Webster-Paki
The Stark Brown picnic - Vinny Tunnell
Gum Digging - Olivia Cheyne

Waitakere City Mayor's PrizesGrowing up Westie - Felix Ovens-Leach
Judges' comments: The author makes a passionate case for why the West is best -
some vivid descriptive writing - keep at it - perhaps we will be reading your
novels or lively non-fiction in years to come?
The history is still alive: a historical research on the history of Little Muddy
Creek and Landing Road - April Crofskey
Judges' comments: Thoughtful and well researched with an excellent use of
photographs - an historian in the making perhaps?

West Auckland Historical Society Prize
The West Auckland Historical Society Prize is awarded in acknowledgement of the
author's considerable time and effort.
Ben Copedo: a passionate historian - Ciara Doran
Judges' comments: A sensitive and thorough piece of original work delightfully
illustrated.

Morris Photographic PrizeThis category is an award for an essay which uses as its starting point an
historic photograph from the library's collection (any collection not just the
Frank Morris Collection) and compares it with a photograph of today, thus
linking the past with the present to make a record for the future.
The changing face of Henderson Valley - Toni Robinson
Judges' comments: With several photographs from the Library's J. T. Diamond
collection juxtaposed against contemporary views of the same location this essay
is a particularly effective study of now and then, describing the changing
landscape and times. Importantly also, all the photographs are accurately
referenced.

The Bullock TrophyThe West Auckland Historical Society Bullock Trophy is presented to the school
that has made a significant contribution in supporting the competition and
originality of topics. The winning school keeps the trophy for a year.
WinnerHenderson Valley School
Judges' comments: 10 entries from this school, all were of a high standard and
they received 8 prizes including the Franich prize for the best overall essay, a
first, 2 seconds, 2 thirds, the West Auckland Historical Society prize, and the
Morris Photographic prize. An outstanding effort and some truly original work.
The judges felt that the children had done their own work - the essays all had
an authentic child's voice but it was also clear that they had received sensible
adult supervision and steering.
Runner upLaingholm Primary
Judges' comments: All essays from this small school were on original topics and
of a high standard - they submitted 4 entries and had 3 place getters a 1st, a
3rd and a Mayor's prize. A great effort.

J.T. Diamond Essay Competition 2008 Prize Winners
Best overall essay: Franich Jewellers Diamond Essay Prize
The 2008 overall winner received diamond jewellery kindly donated by Franich
Jewellers in Henderson.
The Tree Tomato Saga at Landsendt - Annemarie Endt-Ferwerda
Memories category: Adult
First Place
The Tree Tomato Saga at Landsendt - Annemarie Endt-Ferwerda
Judges' comments: Entertaining, informative and well illustrated; an enjoyable
read as well as an historical treasure.
Second Place
One Man's Dream - Justine Fry
Judges' comments: A valuable record of a man and a business that has impacted on
the lives of many a West Aucklander.
Third Place
The Bach at Huia - Olivia Jansen
Judges' comments: A celebration of the magic of Huia, its landscape and
community.

Memories category: Student
First Place
Tina Gouch - Here at Home in West Auckland - Porschia Kirkconnell-Kawana
Judges' comments: Outrageously good! A very moving and original celebration of a
child's extended family. A lovely piece of work and very much connected to the
West.
Second Place
Otawewe - The Cottage of Content - Bridget Hollings
Judges' comments: Gives a strong sense of continuity of enjoyment of a family's
treasured holiday home from a child's point of view.
Third Place
A Huia Legend - The story of a Waitakere Ranger
Judges' comments: Very readable and shows great empathy with the life of a
Ranger.
Highly Commended
Memories of Massey Library - Rachel Burden

Historical Research: Adult
First Prize
Fagan the Bullocky - Rae Atkins
Judges' comments: An evocative recreation of a past time and a real contribution
to the historical record.
Second Prize
Hetana Hamlet - Patricia Earl
Judges' comments: An enjoyable read about a little known subject.
Third Prize
There was no third prize awarded
Highly Commended
A Snapshot of N.Z. Tramping in the 1940s - The Waitakere Tramping
Club - Paul Thurston

Historical Research: Student
First Equal Prize
Peter Maddison - Entomologist of the West - Conor Doran & Molly
O'Connor
Judges' comments: Excellent piece of work. An enthusiastic essay about a subject
which has captured the authors' attention. Well structured and thoroughly
researched. Scientists in the making?
Titirangi Soldier's Memorial Church - Emily Reece
Judges' comments: The student communicates a real interest and emotional
involvement with the subject. Well researched and good use of primary documents,
including photographs.
Second Equal Prize
Paper Bags, Nails and Coffee - The Story of the Hardware Café - Imani
Kerr
Judges' comments: An original piece of work and a valuable contribution to the
historical record, particularly the photographs.
Hooked Since 1952 - A story of the Laingholm Fishing Club - Jack Queenin
Judges' comments: Again, an original topic, well illustrated. A delightful read.
Third Equal Prize
From Rob to Bob - Jacob Morris
Judges' comments: Excellent use of resources. Well referenced and an interesting
read.
The Laingholm Volunteer Fire Brigade - The heart of our Community -
Chloe McLeod
Judges' comments: Delightfully humorous, well researched and good use of
interview material.
The Story Behind the Green Sign - Caitlin Ashcroft
Judges' comments: Well researched and good observations; has made an excellent
use of personal interview material.
Highly Commended
The Old new Lynn Hotel - Alexander Laing
The Historical Hideaway - Brooke Rose Goodison
A Huia Icon for History of the Huia Store - Rowan Hart
The Lovely Life Living in Laingholm - Niko Notman
The dream that Wasn't: The Settlers of Cornwallis - Adam Dewar
Prehistoric Animals and Bones Found in West Auckland - Rize Michau
Whenuapai: Dead or Alive - Elliot Crossan
The Life of a Racing Legend - Kieran Mudgway
A Brief History of Karekare Surf Life Saving Club - Ayrton Sheach
St Ninian's Presbyterian Church: A Mystery Unsolved - Mia-Sophie Kober

Waitakere City Mayor's Prize
The Mayor's Prize is awarded to the essay that vividly portrays personal
memories.
The Story of the Piha Surf Club - Jordynn Brokken
Judges' comments: Well told, the student was very involved with the topic and
the place. An original piece of work with an authentic child's voice and well
researched.
West Auckland Historical Society Prize
The West Auckland Historical Society Prize is awarded in acknowledgement of
the author's considerable time and effort.
5 State Houses in Rata St. 1946 to 57
Judges' comments: A real addition to the historical record. Densely packed with
a wealth of details. Brings the community to life in a vivid way.
The Bullock Trophy
The West Auckland Historical Society Bullock Trophy is presented to the
school that has made a significant contribution in supporting the competition
and originality of topics. The winning school keeps the trophy for a year.
Henderson Valley School
Judges' comments: With two firsts, a second and the Mayor's Prize, this school
entered not only a large number of essays, but they were of an excellent
standard - well researched and original.
J.T. Diamond Essay Competition 2007 Prize Winners
Best overall essay: Franich Jewellers Diamond Essay Prize
The 2007 overall winner received diamond earrings, kindly donated by Franich
Jewellers in Henderson.
The Bach by the Wharf: Cornwallis Beach - Mia Brown
Judges' comments: Quite brilliant! This talented young author has created a
lasting testimony through this essay of the importance of this dwelling and its
associated people and memories. An original piece of work with a resonance well
beyond the personal to a larger New Zealand experience.
Memories category: Adult
First Place
Crown Lynn Potteries in the 1960s - Tony Goodwin
Judges' comments: Excellent. Gives a valuable insight into technical aspects of
Crown Lynn, interspersed with personal anecdotes. An evocative, entertaining and
interesting essay.
Second Place
Memories of a Huia Lass- Gwen Wilkinson
Judges' comments: Evocative in every way. An essay not only detailing a
particular family, but which also brings to life a sense of the Huia Community
in the 50s and 60s and connects through to the present.
Third Place
A Childhood in New Windsor - Sylvia Thomas
Judges' comments: Well written and nostalgic. A strong evocation of a bygone era
with much local details well recorded.

Memories category: Student
First Place
The Bach by the Wharf: Cornwallis Beach - Mia Brown
Judges' comments: Outstanding. "It's got life, death and everything in between."
Six generations and 100 years of family history, movingly documented in
photographs and personal recollections.
Second Equal Place
Waikumete Cemetery: Photo essay with a quartet of poems - A'aone
Malifa, Caitlin Turnbull, Kirsten Turnbull and Perry Wilton
Judges' comments: A creative and powerful piece of work.
Memories of Arahoe School - Emily Thompson
Judges' comments: Well written and makes effective use of personal narrative, as
well as good connections between the past and the present.
Third Place
Caravans Galore - Jessica Thompson
Judges' comments: Splendid work. Delightful choice of photographs. An original
choice of subject and a fascinating story. A real contribution for the record.

Historical Research: Adult
First Prize
A Man to Remember! - Cheryl Clarke-Jowsey
Judges' comments: A well written essay which documents changing land use and
development of a well known area of West Auckland, it also tells the story of an
extraordinary, but largely unrecognised individual, Bill Miller
Second Prize
There was no second prize awarded
Third Prize
There was no third prize awarded
Highly Commended
Steel Boat-building in Kelston at the Span Farm in the late 50s and
60s - Gerhard Breekvelt
Moderne Houses: New Lynn - Patricia Earl

Historical Research: Student
First Prize
The Roundabout: The story of a little community paper that thought
big - Callum Doyle
Judges' comments: An original topic well researched using primary sources.
Second Prize
Dean Buchanan - Sian Loughran
Judges' comments: Based largely on correspondence with the artist, this essay
demonstrates an enthusiasm for the subject and an appreciation of Dean
Buchanan's artistic sensibilities interspersed with personal thoughtful
comments.
Third Equal Prize
Organic Fame - Maisie Leigh Hamilton Murray
Judges' comments: This research into the founders of Phoenix drinks is original
and interesting, and make a real contribution to the field. Wonderful questions,
delightful answers and an authentic child's voice.
The Laingholm Primary School: The greatest little school in the universe - Sam
Maree Wardell
Judges' comments: Well written and based on personal interviews this is a
delightful piece of research.
Highly Commended
Ferndale/Carey Park - Alexander Redman and Sean Donald
Home of the Deaf Lovers: The Karamatura Loop walk, stream & valley - Alisha Hart
and Kulani Nin
Techniques and Transport used in Historical Kauri Logging - Daniel Swann
West Lynn Gardens - Dikun Ong
Bob Harvey Mayor Extraordinaire: Our true Eco-Mayor - Ella Karreback
Church on the Hill - Jordan Curtis and Hannah Curtis
My Rugby Club - Kenny Malolo
Clay, Rock and Sand: The story of the Upper and Lower Huia dams - Lauren Woon
A Little Gem in Huia: The tale of a small farm and museum with big dreams -
Mallory Doherty
Stutzes on Sand: A history of beach racing at Muriwai - Martin Boyle
A Brief History of Glen Eden Railway Station - Michael Boag

Mayor's Prize
The Mayor's Prize is awarded to the essay that vividly portrays personal
memories.
Huia Camp 7th Auckland Boys Brigade - Tony Goodwin
Judges' comments: A strong sense of continuity from childhood to adulthood is
described in this essay. It demonstrates the impact of early experiences in
shaping an appreciation of the natural world, and in particular for the author's
beloved Waitakere Ranges.
West Auckland Historical Society Prize
The West Auckland Historical Society Prize is awarded in acknowledgement of
the author's considerable time and effort.
Shopping in Henderson in the 1930s - Jack Morris
Judges' comments: This 'walking tour' of commercial Henderson in the 1930s
(Maurice Gee's 'Loomis'), is a valuable and well illustrated historical
contribution.
The Bullock Trophy
The West Auckland Historical Society Bullock Trophy is presented to the
school that has made a significant contribution in supporting the competition.
The winning school keeps the trophy for a year.
Henderson Valley School
Judges' comments: This school submitted five entries and three received
recognition, a first, second and highly commended. All were original topics and
used original research. All have made a real contribution to the historical
record for West Auckland. An excellent effort.

J.T. Diamond Essay Competition 2006
Prize Winners
Best overall essay: Franich Jewellers Diamond Essay Prize
The 2006 overall winner received a gold and diamond pendant, donated by
Franich Jewellers in Henderson.
Aunt Dorothy's Memories of Sunnydale - Annemarie Endt
Judges' comments: This essay makes a wonderful contribution to the historical
record, containing information that is simply not available from any published
source. The author has married memories with some solid research and created a
vivid description about family life in the early 1900's. The entire essay is
delightful to read.
Memories category: Adult
First Place
Aunt Dorothy's Memories of Sunnydale - Annemarie Endt
Judges' comments: This very well written, descriptive essay creates an evocative
picture of the period and the people. It draws on the memories of both the
author and long time Oratia resident Dorothy Alice Davidson, known to Oratia
locals as Aunt Dorothy.
Second Place
Henderson - Jewel in the West - Kath Vanderwee
Judges' comments: This essay starts with the author as a child and uses a
timeline through the decades to give a picture of Henderson. The essay contains
delightful and sometimes humorous descriptions and language to convey an
evocative image of Henderson and the west coast.Third Place
Bill Strid: Going Back in Time a Little - Marc Bonny
Judges' comments: This essay is full of both lovely personal tales and
descriptive information on businesses in Henderson during the 1930's.

Memories category: Student
First Place
History of Crum Park - Caitlin Davey
Judges' comments: This essay combines well written historical information with
amusing anecdotes to paint a picture of children playing at Crum Park.
Second Place
John Thompson - Lucy Dixon
Judges' comments: This well written biography uses personal information from the
pre and post war period to tell the story of long time Laingholm resident John
Thompson.
Third Place
Woodlands Park School - Alexandra Holt
Judges' comments: The author has made good use of dates, a brief interview and
general information to produce a nicely written history of Woodlands Park
School.
Historical Research: Adult
First Prize
Willie Sharp - Paul Thurston
Judges' comments: The research for this essay has been skilfully undertaken and
a very readable and well written biography has been produced. It tells the story
of Willie Sharp of Oratia who enlisted under his brother Gordon's name so he
could fight in World War One.
Second Prize
Auckland's First Settlement at Cornwallis - Julie Redman
Judges' comments: This well written essay uses a number of resources to create
an evocative story that describes the hardships the early settlers faced and the
history of the settlement in the wilderness that was Cornwallis.Third Prize
There was no third prize awarded.
Historical Research: Student
First Equal Prize
The History of Whatipu Wharf - Georgia Harris
Judges' comments: This essay is well written, well researched and uses a variety
of resources, including a personal interview, to provide interesting and
comprehensive information about the Whatipu wharf.
First Equal Prize
The Timber Industry in 19th Century West Auckland - Louisa Shen
Judges' comments: This is a well researched and well written essay that draws
together a large amount of information from a wide variety of resources to
describe the development of the timber industry in West Auckland. Third
Prize
The Nihotupu Dams - Georgia Rae
Judges' comments: This essay is both interesting and nicely written, with a good
bibliography and appropriate photographs.
Mayor's Prize
The Mayor's Prize is awarded to the essay that vividly portrays personal
memories.
Wine Makers and Their Labels - Jack Morris
Judges' comments:
This entry combines comprehensive historical information with lovely anecdotes.
It is a valuable contribution to the history of the vineyards and wineries of
West Auckland.
West Auckland Historical Society Prize
The West Auckland Historical Society Prize is awarded in acknowledgement of the
author's considerable time and effort.
Fond Memories of West Auckland - Elizabeth Elphinstone
Judges' comment: This interesting essay creates an evocative description about
growing up on a farmlet in Titirangi.
J.T Diamond Essay Competition 2005 Prize Winners
To request copies of the essays contact
Waitakere Library & Information
Services.
Prize Winners
Best overall essay: Franich Jewellers Diamond Essay Prize
For 2005 the recipient received a gold and diamond pendant donated by Franich
Jewellers of Henderson.
Emma Louise Joyce -
Tenuous tenancies: a history of the Cornwallis baches
Judges' comments: A very polished essay that combined research with evocative
writing. Everything about it was 'top class.'
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Tenuous tenancies: a
history of the Cornwallis baches (Size 1030K)
Memories category
First Place
Dianne Cooper -
Holiday memories: Piha in the 50s to mid 60s
Judges' comments: An evocative essay that created a strong sense of time and
place with emotional resonance.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Holiday memories: Piha in
the 50s to mid 60s (Size 18K)
Second Place
Dick Endt -
A new life in New Zealand: fond memories of the clay-adobe house on Parker Road,
Oratia
Judges' comments: A delightful read which created a clear picture of an historic
building, now sadly destroyed.
Third Place
Glennys McGlashan -
Memories of Te Atatu in the 1960s
Judges' comments: A well written and fascinating account of the often ignored
subject of the life of women at home.
Highly commended
Mayor's Prize
Cyril Kelleway -
A mini supermarket comes to West Auckland
Judges' comments: The writer developed a strong sense of time and place which
created an appealing essay.
Historical research category
First Prize
Emma Louise Joyce -
Tenuous tenancies: a history of the Cornwallis baches
Judges' comments: The essay contained a tremendous amount of research that
was both well presented and an enjoyable read.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Tenuous tenancies: a
history of the Cornwallis baches (Size 1030K)
Second Equal Prize
Nigel Brookes -
From Green Bay to Gondwanaland
Judges' comments: A simple question was answered using an unique and
informative approach.
Second Equal Prize
Carolyn Melling -
The lonely grave
Judges' comments: An evocative essay that drew together research from a diverse
range of resources.
Highly commended
West Auckland Historical Society Prize
Rob & Patricia Carr -
Pinesong in Green Bay
Judges' comment: This essay crafted considerable research into an enjoyable
read.
Children's Prize
Mercedes Bishop -
History of West Auckland bush land
Judges' comments: The writer drew together some interesting concepts through a
combination of primary research and secondary resources.
Copies of all the essays are available to view at the J.T. Diamond Research
Room, Henderson Library.

J.T Diamond Essay Competition 2004
To request copies of the essays contact
Waitakere Library & Information
Services.
Prize winners
Amateur Historian
First place
Ray Ryan (of Porirua) -Winning Posts
Judges' comments: This essay about one man's efforts to build a boundary fence
through part of Centennial Park is a well-written anecdotal account. It touches
on what makes life in West Auckland especially unique. The writer, a young boy
at the time; recounts these days with his great uncle Horace Mobbs.
The essay, accompanied by photographs, combines personal memories with
well-researched information and faithfully represents the pioneer spirit of
yesteryear.
Note: You will need to have
Adobe Acrobat Reader
installed on your computer in order to view and print this document. For
help opening PDF files or tips on copying information see Helpful
Tips.
Winning Posts (Size
1532K)
Second place
David Peppiatt (of Henderson) -
A Time to Die - How Destruction Gully got its name.
Judges' comments: Any effort to document a pre-European history of Maori is
ambitious. The accuracy of available resource material is totally reliant on the
oral tradition as there were no written accounts. This means the lines between
fact and fiction are often blurred. This has been acknowledged in the writer's
preamble where he refers to several "quite contradictory accounts" found during
his research. However, he settled for the two most probable versions to assist
with his writing. The result is a thorough and well researched essay, with an
impressive bibliography that documents the events leading to an infamous battle
involving Te Kawerau a Maki.
Third place
Graeme Gummer (of Papatoetoe) -
A Bach in the Waitakere Ranges in the 1930's.
Judges' comments: This is an account of a visit to a remote Bach or shelter
with the most primitive of facilities spread over a period of a few days. All
the comforts of home were left behind and the writer took on survival mode at
the mercy of his companion's knowledge of the area. A delightfully written,
personal account of a time gone by.

Highly Commended
Winston Hansen (of Glen Eden)
Alf's Purpose, Alf's Way
Juliette Patterson (of Henderson)
The Man who brought a Special Sparkle and Unique Sound to West Auckland
Yvonne (Sally) Willmot (of Hobsonville)
Whenuapai Airbase, Up, Up and Away
Judges' comments: These entries were chosen for a highly commended prize
because they told their stories so well, with good backup research where needed.
All delightful stories of unique characters and places in our West Auckland
history.

Intermediate Category
First place
Thomas Brockwell-Parker (of Acorn Academy) -
Travel Through Time
Judges' comments: This entry contained original research with a wide breadth
of well-written and logical progression. A well presented chronological history
of the Glen Eden railway station between 1876 and 2004. It contained a good
selection of photography to give further colour. Very well done.
Second place
Loi Fuimaono (of Acorn Academy) -
The Old Methodist Church in Glen Eden
Judges' comments: A very well researched and detailed essay with good
resources and excellent use of oral history. This entry, accompanied by an
excellent set of photographs, puts the resulting information to good use as a
comprehensive history of the church since its early days in the old mortuary
chapel at Waikumete Cemetery. Congratulations for the attention to detail while
researching this topic.
Third equal
Siobhan Vanwaas-Doyle (of Glen Eden Intermediate) -
The Story of the Cornwallis Wharf
Judges' comments: Evocative writing style and good photographs that
compliment the story. Much detail of the work needed to upgrade and rebuild the
wharf. Covers the history of the wharf to present days.
Arielle Wakelin (of Henderson) -
The Falls Hotel
Judges' comments: This entry refers to many jottings and research, including
work by Jack Diamond before updating the old buildings, as well as more recent
history of its relocation and upgrade. It also covers the paid car parking
system. This entry was well presented and thorough, with good accompanying
photographs.

Audio / Visual
Krystle Barnes (of Te Atatu Peninsula) -
Westie Winemakers
Judges' comments: Krystle's entry was the one that most fitted the criteria.
There were some very interesting extracts and it was well researched. The whole
presentation was well edited and thoughtfully put together, providing a good
overview of a local industry.
West Auckland Historical Society " Bullock Team Trophy
(for a school project)
Glen Eden Intermediate
The West Auckland Historical Society presented this trophy to Glen Eden
Intermediate for their excellent work and accurate portrayal of the on-going
history of the area. This entry followed the spirit of Jack Diamond's work.

West Auckland Historical Society Prize (most promising essay and an
acknowledgement of time and effort)
W N Bishop (of Glen Eden) -
Memories of Titirangi
Judges' comments: A lengthy account of life in Titirangi, this essay covers
many topics which would all make good subjects for individual essays.
Mayor's Prize (presented to the essay portraying personal memories most
vividly).
Annemarie Endt (of Oratia) -148 Edmonton Road
Judges' comments: Memories that tell an immigrants point of view and first
impressions when relocating to another country. It recounts the need to bring
and build their house.
|